Flag

We stand with Ukraine and our team members from Ukraine. Here are ways you can help

Get exclusive access to thought-provoking articles, bonus podcast content, and cutting-edge whitepapers. Become a member of the UX Magazine community today!

Home ›› Behavioral Science ›› Will Conversational AI and Experience Design Revolutionize the Behavioral Sciences?

Will Conversational AI and Experience Design Revolutionize the Behavioral Sciences?

by Daniel Lametti
5 min read
Share this post on
Tweet
Share
Post
Share
Email
Print

Save

Will Conversational AI and Experience Design Revolutionize the Behavioral Sciences?

One author’s thoughts on progress of behavioral sciences over the last 50 years and ways conversational AI and experience design revolutionize them.

Every year, thousands of undergraduates at universities across North America donate their minds to science. Seeking pay or course credit, students report to labs in concrete psychology buildings to fill out questionnaires on their thoughts, feelings, and beliefs. If, at some point, you took Psych 101 there’s a good chance you’ve contributed a data point to psychological research, or at least been asked to by your professor. 

Throughout the 20th century, laboratory studies with undergraduates shaped our understanding of the human mind. But these studies have known flaws. The most common participants in lab-based behavioural research are students studying psychology, and the psychology of psychology students does not reflect that of the wider population. The laboratory environment adds another source of bias to lab-based research. Under the researchers’ glare, participants may adjust their responses to appear more socially acceptable—or alter their memories of events to meet the perceived demands of the survey. As technology has evolved, new methods have emerged to improve the quality of collected data. Many of these improvements have worked well because they improved the quality of the experience test subjects have while providing data—an area where conversational AI can provide remarkable upgrades.

To combat problems associated with lab-based research, psychologists in the 1970s developed the experience sampling method. In experience sampling studies, participants are prompted to describe their thoughts, feelings, and actions at random times throughout the day. Recorded thoughts and emotional states are thus tethered, not to the psychology lab, but to the real-world events in which they actually occur—watching television, attending school, mindlessly scrolling social media.   

Before the Internet, experience sampling was done using pagers distributed to participants at the start of a study. The pagers were used to signal participants with a beep or a buzz at random times throughout the day. When a signal was received, the participant had to stop whatever they were doing and quickly fill out a paper-and-pencil based survey designed to probe a psychological trait. “How do you feel right now?” and, “What are you doing?” were common questions that followed a ping. 

Throughout the 1970s, ‘80s, and ‘90s, this method, although tedious and geographically limited (the pagers had a range of about 60 miles), was used extensively by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi—a psychologist known for describing a heightened state of productivity dubbed flow. Csikszentmihalyi used experience sampling to test associations between behaviour and emotions: What, for instance, was the relationship between daily activities and happiness? Socialising and eating predicted happiness, it turned out, while sadness was associated with binge-watching television. 

Recently, the internet has revolutionised how behavioural researchers interact with participants. Many studies are now run online through social media or dedicated websites like Gorilla.sc or SurveyMonkey, a practice accelerated by the global pandemic. In contemporary experience sampling studies, participants interact with an app or respond to a text on their smartphone; the device then records their responses and transmits the data back to researchers. The mass adoption of smartphones has also made it easier to take samples from huge numbers of participants—a difficult task in the days of pagers and paper-and-pencil questionnaires. Larger samples increase the likelihood that the collected responses actually reflect the views of the wider population, as opposed to the views of undergraduates in psychology programs. 

In one highly cited app-based study, researchers Matthew Killingsworth and Daniel Gilbert built and distributed an iPhone app that pinged American adults at random times throughout the day. They were then asked three questions: “How are you feeling right now?”, “What are you doing right now?”, and “Are you thinking about something other than what you’re currently doing?” Responses from more than two thousand participants showed that nearly 50% of the time people were not thinking about what they were doing, and this mind wandering was associated with feelings of unhappiness. As the authors put it, “a human mind is a wandering mind, and a wandering mind is an unhappy mind”. This result, which supports a claimed benefit of mindfulness, would not have been revealed without the internet and smartphones.  

What’s next for real-world studies of human behaviour? The proliferation of AI has driven rapid changes in several academic fields, from archival studies to particle physics. An AI built by Google’s DeepMind recently predicted the structure of nearly every possible protein—an unimaginable task a decade ago. (PhD theses have been dedicated to describing the structure of single proteins.) 

In behavioural research like psychology, AI may have its largest impact through conversation. Not only can an app-based AI such as those deployed by OneReach.ai or IBM sample behaviour through a smartphone, but, like a researcher in a lab, it can engage with participants as they report their experiences. Using natural language understanding, data can be collected and, on the fly, behavioural interventions can be tested and optimised for each participant. Reports of specific thoughts and feelings over text or voice can initiate follow-up questions and suggested interventions. An AI could respond to reports of sadness, for instance, with a suggested activity or “nudge” known to boost positive emotions, like a run in the park. Severe psychological distress could trigger an AI to call a family member or a psychologist. Of course, interactions like these require attention to experience design that accounts for the many nuances that make up effective speech and text-based conversations.

This might be part of the reason why commercially available experience sampling apps have yet to incorporate conversational AI. But in a view of what’s possible, several mental health apps have recently made an attempt. While working on this piece I installed Elomia, a mental health chatbot, on my phone and conversed with the AI about my workload. “There’s too much to do and not enough time,” I whined to the bot. “We can figure out which tasks are the most important,” it calmly replied, “and tackle them one at a time”. Following Elomia’s urging, I then broke my to-do list down into a series of more manageable tasks, two of which included researching and writing this piece. I then researched and wrote this piece.  

Of course, Elomia’s advice was obvious—a simple solution to a simple problem. The chatbot was not a replacement for my therapist. Still, in our short interaction the bot sampled a source of in-the-moment stress and suggested a solution with my input. This interaction was akin to that which might occur in a more conventional lab-based study. Without knowing it, the bot was doing dynamic behavioural research in the real world. 

Twenty years ago, the internet enabled the movement of behavioural research from the lab to the real world. This change markedly increased our understanding of human behaviour. Although conversational AI has yet to be widely adopted in research, the ability to talk to machines has the potential to once again revolutionise how research is conducted in the behavioural sciences. And what we learn from these conversations may fundamentally shape our understanding of the human mind.

post authorDaniel Lametti

Daniel Lametti

Dan Lametti is an Associate Professor of Psycholinguistics at Acadia University in Nova Scotia, Canada. He is also the Director of Academic Fellowships at OneReach.ai. Prior to these roles, Dan taught and conducted research in experimental psychology at the University of Oxford. He also helped develop and fund neuroscience and mental health research as a science advisor at the Wellcome Trust. Dan holds a PhD in Cognitive Psychology from McGill University and an undergraduate degree in Physics from Bishop’s University.

Tweet
Share
Post
Share
Email
Print
Ideas In Brief
  • The article covers:
    • Studies and surveys on behavioral sciences conducted over the last 50 years
    • The role of conversational AI in the modern world and its perks
    • Ways conversational AI and experience design might revolutionize behavioral sciences

Related Articles

AI is reshaping the role of designers, shifting them from creators to curators. This article explores how AI tools are changing design workflows, allowing designers to focus more on strategy and user experience. Discover how this shift is revolutionizing the design process and the future of creative work.

Article by Andy Budd
The Future of Design: How AI Is Shifting Designers from Makers to Curators
  • This article examines how AI is transforming the role of designers, shifting them from creators to curators.
  • It explores how AI tools are enhancing design processes by automating routine tasks, allowing designers to focus on strategic decision-making and curating user experiences.
  • The piece highlights the growing importance of creativity in managing AI-driven systems and fostering collaboration across teams, ultimately reshaping the future of design work.
Share:The Future of Design: How AI Is Shifting Designers from Makers to Curators
5 min read

Are you overthinking your research process? This article explores how to determine when research is essential and when it might be holding you back. Learn a practical framework to prioritize studies, align with stakeholders, and maximize impact without wasting time or resources. Unlock strategies to focus your efforts on what truly matters.

Article by Carol Rossi
Are You Doing Too Much Research?
  • The article questions the common practice of conducting extensive research, suggesting that not all projects require it. Instead, it highlights the importance of discerning when research is truly necessary.
  • It introduces a framework to prioritize research efforts based on clarity, risk, and cost, ensuring impactful results without unnecessary delays.
  • The author emphasizes the role of stakeholder involvement in the research process, fostering better collaboration and alignment with organizational goals.
  • Practical strategies are provided for tracking and communicating the post-research impact, making the value of research more transparent and measurable.
Share:Are You Doing Too Much Research?
7 min read

Learn how to design and facilitate impactful co-creation sessions that inspire collaboration, spark creativity, and align diverse perspectives for meaningful outcomes.

Article by Aalap Doshi
Designing and Facilitating a Co-Creation Session
  • This article delves into the process of designing and facilitating effective co-creation sessions to foster collaborative innovation.
  • It outlines key steps, including planning, creating a structured agenda, and using tools to engage participants meaningfully.
  • The piece highlights how co-creation sessions can drive creativity, align diverse stakeholders, and generate actionable outcomes for complex challenges.
Share:Designing and Facilitating a Co-Creation Session
3 min read

Join the UX Magazine community!

Stay informed with exclusive content on the intersection of UX, AI agents, and agentic automation—essential reading for future-focused professionals.

Hello!

You're officially a member of the UX Magazine Community.
We're excited to have you with us!

Thank you!

To begin viewing member content, please verify your email.

Tell us about you. Enroll in the course.

    This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Check our privacy policy and