Flag

We stand with Ukraine and our team members from Ukraine. Here are ways you can help

Get exclusive access to thought-provoking articles, bonus podcast content, and cutting-edge whitepapers. Become a member of the UX Magazine community today!

Home ›› Design ›› When does UX Design become Service Design?

When does UX Design become Service Design?

by Anish Joshi
5 min read
Share this post on
Tweet
Share
Post
Share
Email
Print

Save

LeadBannerserviceux

Even though I’m never keen to create silos in Design, this is a distinction worth exploring.

I interview many people and often apologise before I ask the clichéd question of, “How do you define Service Design, and how do you define UX Design — what is it that makes them different?”

UX Design (Experience Design), fuelled by the rise of digital, has become more established these days with some great work being done the field. It has naturally been expanding into the realms of ‘Service Design’*, but I’ve noticed that what constitutes people’s understanding of Service Design, and a Service Designer, appears to misalign with what I believe the criteria and components are.

* there is also a route into Service Design (to a lesser extent) from the other direction, i.e. where businesses are trying to shape services from a human-centred viewpoint.

To help illustrate how I see it, here’s a quick model I drew up.

1

At its centre and start point is what I think and hope everyone agrees is definitely UX Design -as thought of in the market place (there is of course more than this, and that’s what we will explore). This is the practice of creating a digital function, process or experience at a touch point; commonly illustrated through journeys, user stories, flows, wireframes and screens (or of course these days, also audio, VR etc.).

Now, I’ve noticed 4 dimensions, or 4 components, through which, when people cross or perform, they believe they have moved from the world of UX Design into Service Design.

First — Research

2

I’ve noticed that the act of doing research, yes, more generative, wider, ethnographic and behaviour research, and not the more evaluative, narrower research normally associated with testing for a touchpoint solution, has started to be seen as ‘Service Design’. In my book this is still just Research. Invaluable and necessary, and all the better for it being wider in scope and depth, but it is still Research.

Let’s be clear, Research does not equal Service Designalthough that generative, holistic level of research is the critical starting/building blocks for good Service Design.

Research is and should be an essential for UX design; its scope is up to you. So if you’re doing research, you’re still in the realm of (good) UX Design.

Next — Physical Vs Digital

3

Some start suggesting that once we start looking beyond the digital interface (screen, voice, or virtual), then this becomes Service Design. I think if we look at the literal word ‘Experience’ the clue is in there. Our experiences are always made up of more than interactions with digital objects. The physical — whether that be products, or spaces, or conversations, is absolutely key in our perception of an experience.

So even if you’re defining and designing both the physical and digital, that’s still UX design. They are both delivering an experience to the end user/customer.

Again, thinking about the physical aspects of any experience, is a key part of service design, but by itself it is not/not equal to Service Design.

Singular Vs Multi Touchpoint

4

Next, I’ve seen that when the design of something expands beyond looking at a singular touchpoint of interaction, and across a multi or omni-channel journey; where a user has a variety of interactions, with different devices (or people, or systems, or business areas) then this is seen as Service Design.

Closer and warmer, but not quite. While this level of thinking has reached more holistic heights and covers a multitude of exchanges along a journey, it is still predominantly looking at how the person (user, employee, customer) is experiencing, or acting with, something, to result in an outcome.

Good UX should automatically consider the experience of a user or customer across the whole journey regardless of path or medium.

Again, thinking end-to-end through a whole journey, and over multiple use cases, is the bedrock of good Service Design, but by itself solely, it isn’t Service Design.

Front stage Vs Back stage

5

Now we’re talking. This (in my book) is where experience design makes the hop skip and jump into Service Design. Again if we look literally, it reads as ‘the design of a service’. The key here is that a Service, is both the experience that is delivered, as well as the back-stage, internal nuts and bolts workings (whether by a business or organisation) that needs to be defined and take place so that it can deliver on that front-of-stage experience. In this way, the experience is the effect of designing that service.

This is the crux of Service design. It is the behind the scenes goings-on (processes, governance, organisational structures, change management, policies, culture even) that need to be designed and crafted in a human centred way such that a human centred front-of-stage experience can be delivered. And to do this well, that person needs to have a greater sense of business knowledge & acumen, blended with the core talents of being a designer; creativity, critical thinking and collaboration.

This is the dimension that needs to be crossed to qualify as Service Design.

[To clarify; front stage does not have to be a customer or external user, but could also be an internal employee i.e where UX is EX. The backstage is the functionings or the mechanisms that facilitate that/any experience like the elements of change management, governance etc mentioned above]

6

Now, by going through this arc, what I am also saying and agreeing with, is that Service Design DOES indeed include key elements such as generative research, ‘beyond the digital’ thinking, and end-to-end, multi media shaping, but just that any one of these, or even all three of them, do not equate to Service Design itself. They are the foundations and the keystones, but one must look at how we design the backstage service/process to be Service Designers.

… and if we continue along this dimension’s trajectory we will get to business design, but that’s for another blog.

post authorAnish Joshi

Anish Joshi

Anish is currently Head of Design & Innovation for Shell where he is helping to create, from the ground up, a new worldwide digital innovation lab capability that sets out to develop products and services through design, lean innovation and agile methodologies, coupled with new technologies. He champions a holistic human centred proposition from design thinking and service design, through to digital creation (UX & UI); leading, managing and creating, strategic, digital and physical work, blended with a solid business understanding that pushes beyond current trends into future focused innovation.

Anish has an Executive MBA at Imperial college London where he has also explored how strategic design can combine with business in original ways.

Tweet
Share
Post
Share
Email
Print

Related Articles

AI is reshaping UX, and Figma may be sinking. As AI-driven systems minimize UI, traditional design roles must evolve — or risk becoming obsolete. Are you ready to adapt?

Article by Greg Nudelman
AI Is Flipping UX Upside Down: How to Keep Your UX Job, and Why Figma is a Titanic (It’s not for the Reasons You Think)
  • The article explores the fundamental shift in UX as AI-first systems minimize the role of UI, rendering traditional design tools like Figma increasingly obsolete.
  • It introduces the “Iceberg UX Model,” illustrating how modern AI-driven interfaces prioritize functionality and automation over visual design.
  • The piece argues that UX professionals must shift their focus from UI aesthetics to AI-driven user experience, emphasizing use case validation, AI model integration, and data-informed decision-making.
  • It warns that designers who remain fixated on pixel-perfect layouts risk becoming obsolete, urging them to adapt by engaging in AI-driven UX strategies.
Share:AI Is Flipping UX Upside Down: How to Keep Your UX Job, and Why Figma is a Titanic (It’s not for the Reasons You Think)
7 min read

Data visualization isn’t just about charts — it’s about telling a clear and compelling story. This article unpacks a wide spectrum of essential principles for making data easy to understand, honest, and engaging. Ready to transform complex numbers into meaningful insights?

Article by Jim Gulsen
The Ultimate Data Visualization Handbook for Designers
  • The article serves as a comprehensive guide for elevating visualization work, combining technical expertise with design principles to help designers transform raw data into meaningful insights.
  • It provides a point of reference for strategies, methods, and best practices to create more effective and impactful data visualizations.
  • The piece recommends tools and resources that design professionals can immediately implement to enhance the clarity and persuasiveness of their data storytelling.
Share:The Ultimate Data Visualization Handbook for Designers
23 min read

Indonesia’s retail landscape is shifting fast. From digital giants to local shops, businesses are adapting with new strategies to stay ahead. What’s driving the change, and who’s winning the retail game? Find out here.

Article by Thasya Ingriany
Scenarios of Change: How Retail Adapts to Economic Shifts in Indonesia
  • The article explores how Indonesia’s retail sector is adapting to economic shifts, balancing digital transformation and traditional strategies.
  • It highlights how large e-commerce platforms are thriving by offering competitive pricing and flexible payment options, while traditional retailers embrace omnichannel strategies to stay relevant.
  • The piece emphasizes the growing importance of hyperlocal retailing, trust-building through immersive brand experiences, and loyalty programs that drive consumer engagement.
Share:Scenarios of Change: How Retail Adapts to Economic Shifts in Indonesia
15 min read

Join the UX Magazine community!

Stay informed with exclusive content on the intersection of UX, AI agents, and agentic automation—essential reading for future-focused professionals.

Hello!

You're officially a member of the UX Magazine Community.
We're excited to have you with us!

Thank you!

To begin viewing member content, please verify your email.

Tell us about you. Enroll in the course.

    This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Check our privacy policy and