It’s a common misconception that art and design are one and the same. But although design can be artful, the process behind it is quite different.

Artists engage in the manipulation of a particular medium to produce an aesthetic and personal response. Art is valued for its originality and ability to express an idea. Some people get it, some don’t, and that’s okay. Design, on the other hand, must solve a specific problem relative to a particular user or task, and is evaluated simply by how effective it is at solving that problem. If it doesn’t work, then it failed—period.

Everything in nature is the way it is by design; evolution has no aesthetic or personal opinion. Like art, some people find bugs to be quite beautiful while others cringe at the sight of them. But like them or not, their design is the way it is because of their environment and the obstacles they face trying to survive. In other words, it doesn’t matter what you think; it has to work, or they die.

Design is inherently an objective process, yet when it comes to designing for people, we tend to cloud this truth. As emotional beings, our judgment is often greatly affected by how we feel, and how we feel is often unpredictable, uncertain, and complicated. Therefore, we can’t design for emotion; everyone experiences it differently. But we can design for the fundamental psychological underpinnings and biological traits that influence perception. When we do that, we find design to be much simpler. All we must do is define a core concept—a problem to solve—and make logical, subsequent decisions off it, maintaining focus and keeping in mind the psychology of how we learn and remember things.

How We Learn

Instinctually, we construct myriad mental models of concepts in the world, creating expectations of how objects work, which we learn more over time through our experiences. We’re naturally inclined to believe, for example, that round things are softer than square things, that blue is colder than orange, and that simpler things and, in general, more approachable.

Consider a person who’s never seen a mobile phone before presented with both an iPhone and a Blackberry. Then consider the range of first moves they can make with each product. By probability alone, there’s a higher chance that the person turns the iPhone on faster than the Blackberry. With less buttons and less clutter, the iPhone is much easier to approach and engage with, and that is its first, and perhaps most important, step to success.

In a battle of popular micro-blogging sites, Tumblr and Posterous take very different approaches to their landing pages. Posterous, a Silicon Valley tech company, showcases how it works and what people say about it. On the other hand, Tumblr, a New York design company, simply presents users with a big signup form and one line of text: “The easiest way to blog.” By focusing users’ attention and presenting them with few options, the product is far more approachable. As such, despite Posterous’s powerful functionality, Tumblr has won out in the size of its user base.

Users’ entire experience with a new product is a continual series of new experiences, making the approachability of those experiences key as they learn new facets and features of the product. But there’s a second, more powerful step to engagement: familiarity.

Recognition is among the most powerful forms of memory recall, so it’s no wonder that familiarity is a strong factor in good design. Because we carry with us all kinds of assumptions and schemas from our innate biology and prior experiences, we don’t approach products as a blank slate. The more a product can tap into users’ existing expectations, the easier it will be for them to learn its new features. Many basic calculator software applications, for example, mimic the look of a real calculator, even though a virtual calculator probably makes more sense as a simple textbox that parses expressions.

A product with a familiar interface gives users a tremendous leg up in the learning process, and meeting their expectations builds a valuable trusting relationship that greatly enhances the product’s quality and credibility.

How We Remember

This continual cycle of approachability and recognizability can be described as learnability—that is, how easy a product is to learn. Because this is a crucial component of a product’s success, more complex products will often put new users through a tutorial-like workflow to get them acquainted with the various features and facets. But this approach suggests that the product has an inherently flawed architecture. If the basic blueprint is not intuitive such that users have to be guided through it, the learning process becomes less internalized and less memorable; they are learning to rely on what you tell them, not what they experience.

Workflows designed with a focus on initial learnability can do more serious damage to a product’s usability in the long run. One of the most challenging aspects to selling a design to stakeholders is convincing them that its usability—the speed and efficiency of task completion—is more important than the initial gut reaction, which is all you get from a meeting. Stakeholders often like to see certain elements front and center from the beginning, never mind that those elements may become trivial—or worse, distracting —in the rest of the workflow. If a product doesn’t have a logical architecture from the start, users will lose their way.

In 2007, Microsoft revamped its suite of Office products with “The Ribbon,” a new interface that organizes related commands into a set of tabs. Years of research and iteration lead to this design, which was intended to optimize the user workflow. In PowerPoint (a product on which I briefly worked), research showed that the typical user workflow consisted primarily of creating a new slide, adding text, formatting that text, adding shapes, and formatting those shapes. As a result, the “Home” tab in The Ribbon includes all these apparently related actions together, with other tabs having names and action sets based on other workflows: “Design,” “Slideshow,” “Insert,” “Review,” and a contextual tab depending on what tool the user has selected.

Powerpoint vs. Keynote
The difference between the PowerPoint and Keynote interfaces.

This structure starkly contrasts the way Apple designed Keynote, another slideshow/presentation application. While its interface also uses a tabbed approach, the tabs are divided by the various types of objects that can be included in presentations: slides, text, shapes, charts, tables, etc., each with its own set of related actions. Because of this more objective and logical grouping (as well as many of Keynote’s other features that obey principles of approachability and recognizability), the product is quite successful and easy to use.

Objective design doesn’t cater to a specific workflow. Rather, it simply provides a logical structure that plays into our innate psychology. This structure is also behind good writing, movies, music, and other widely successful products and experiences. People are inclined to seek out order and hierarchy as a way to categorize, identify, and define the objects and experiences they encounter and don’t respond well to deviations from this natural process.

If someone challenges a product’s design with aesthetically or emotionally based suggestions and changes, they must be reminded that design decisions are based in logical reasoning. It’s this highly disciplined, unemotional, and perceptive ability to break down gray areas into small, inarguable black-and-white building blocks that allow for the most effective communication and, more importantly, designs that just work.

Add new comment


My unruffled protrude:

Project recto moved:

Updated put forth number:

hOur company offers generic pills. Look at our health contributing site in case you want to look better. [url=][/url] Our company offers a wide variety of non prescription drugs. Take a look at our health website in case you want to feel better with a help of generic supplements. [url=][/url] Our company provides a wide variety of non prescription drugs. Visit our health portal in case you want to to improve your health with a help health products. [url=][/url] Our company offers a wide variety of non prescription drugs. Look at our health portal in case you want to to feel healthier with a help health products. [url=][/url] Our company offers a wide variety of non prescription products. Visit our health website in case you want to to improve your health with a help general health products. Our company offers a wide variety of non prescription products. Look at our health site in case you want to strengthen your health with a help of generic supplements. [url=][/url]
Our company provides generic pharmacy. Look at our health contributing portal in case you want to feel better. [url=][/url] Our company provides a wide variety of non prescription products. Visit our health website in case you want to look healthier with a help generic supplements. [url=][/url] Our company provides healthcare products. Look at our health contributing website in case you want to strengthen your health. [url=][/url] Our company offers a wide variety of non prescription drugs. Take a look at our health website in case you want to strengthen your health with a help general health products. Our company offers generic supplements. Take a look at our health contributing portal in case you want to strengthen your health.

My new trap scheme:

[url=]cheap mcm backpack[/url] Selena Gomez Carries Our Favourite MICHAEL Michael Kors Here鈥檚 a polished Selena Gomez, arriving at KISS 100 studios in London to promote her new album and tour, carrying a MICHAEL Michael Kors Selma Bag. This black and white model of this Selma sold out quickly, but a stylish black and grey colorway is still available for $358 at Neiman Marcus. Fortunately for all of us, you do not really have to do double responsibility as being a pop star and actress to add the Selma to your stash.The Selma bags have been especially well known with celebs more than the last handful of months, we鈥檝e seen a wide variety of starlets carrying the Selma in Tote, Satchel, and Messenger form. A lot earlier within the yr, we declared the MICHAEL Michael Kors Selma 鈥渢he finest detail likely under $400鈥? and so many months later, there isn鈥檛 a single designer bag that can challenge its title.It鈥檚 been de rigueur for young, edgy, look-at-me designers to help make handbags out of stuffed animals for several years now. Some veer toward the cute (Mandy Coon and her bunny rabbit), some veer toward the strange (Giles Deacon and his triceratops), and now the Christopher Raeburn Quilted Water Rat Shoulder Bag requires a transform for the decidedly, purposefully grotesque.As revolting given that the thought of the rat is to most people today (especially New Yorkers), the sight of a pink rat (shaved? skinned? who knows.) strikes me as particularly nauseating. On this bag, the Xed eyes give the distinctive impression this minor critter, although created of nylon, is intended to invoke a dead rat, and also a dead swimming rat at that. The mere concept of a water rat is sufficient to preserve me from lakes and ponds with the duration, despite the fact that I鈥檓 not 100% certain that is their natural habitat. I鈥檇 rather not uncover out, and today I鈥檓 afraid to Google anything that could bring up less-than-pleasant photos, lest I locate myself bombarded with this bag鈥檚 real-life inspiration.A bag this odd requires reader input, as far as I鈥檓 concerned, so kindly pick an adjective and place it within the comments. If you are hunting for an expensive strategy to freak out your nieces and impress your nephews, pick up this bag for $328 by way of Matches. [url=]cheap prada[/url] We haven鈥檛 been going crazy bombarding you with Big apple Style 7 days coverage for just a extremely simple reason we know just the best collections to share that you will undoubtably love, but to the past 7 days we鈥檝e been all in excess of NYC to determine the Spring 2014 shows. I鈥檝e seen countless collections I have adored, and obviously awesome bags. We are just more than half way as a result of Big apple Fashion 7 days, and via the very first of Monday鈥檚 demonstrates, these are the 12 ideal luggage thus significantly. When it comes on the baggage, geometric patterns, natural touches and black and white are hunting key for Spring 2014. And that is your favourite?Greater than some other designer at his contemporary price tag point, Alexander Wang has a tendency to place difficult-to-carry bags on his New york Style Week runways. Most related designers use their displays to be a vehicle to introduce their highly profitable marquee accessories to your potentially adoring public, but Wang generally goes the technique for his more-expensive brethren and saves the cash cow baggage for his lookbooks. Instead, his runways feature a handful of handbag shapes that set the tone for what鈥檚 to come from your rest with the collection.It鈥檚 a little bit of the departure, then, that for Spring 2014, most of Wang鈥檚 runway bags glimpse actually wearable. Specifically, the softly geometric clutches search like a certain wager. (Another near-sure bet: they鈥檒l occur with crossbody straps to help make them far more practical once the luggage hit retail.) The oversize satchels will be a tad of the tougher sell, but in scaled-down versions (and Wang almost often releases smaller versions of oversized runway bags), they need to be well-liked by Wang鈥檚 usual followers. Intriguingly, the satchels also appeared to have three-point deal with attachments on their undersides, hinting that perhaps an optional backpack setup will accompany those layouts at retail. How of-the-moment.As we all know by now, Victora Beckham鈥檚 is among the rare celebrity fashion strains done correct. Not only does Beckham鈥檚 brand make a cocktail frock along with the kind of painstaking tailoring you really don't come across many places, although the precision extends towards the line鈥檚 excellent handbags and shoes, the latter of which are in collaboration with Manolo Blahnik. I only wish that Beckham鈥檚 Spring 2014 runway luggage arrived in much more styles.Instead, Beckham selected mostly to stick together with the duffels and clutches that have seen success for her during the previous, besides now they鈥檙e re-imagined on a extra petite scale and within a triangular print that was mirrored during the collection鈥檚 dresses. Like quite a few of latest York鈥檚 collections, the baggage were fashioned mainly outside of light neutrals, using a healthy dose of black in this article and there. Beckham could be British, but this really is Ny, just after all.

[url=]prada tote bag[/url] Jessica Alba Gets the Appear for Less with Phillip Lim We like a good high-low collab, and Phillip Lim for Target is the greatest one to appear together in eons. The Target-Phillip Lim lovefest officially commenced this 7 days which has a snazzy NYFW launch party. Here鈥檚 Jessica Alba, completely ready to party hard that has a sharp-looking 3.1 Phillip Lim for Target Satchel - her sweater is within the line as well. All of these celeb-endorsed goodies hit Target stores nationwide September 15th!The real litmus test for Phillip Lim for Target is going to be obviously, if we see a single celeb carrying 1 their freebie baggage immediately after September 15th. (You are going to surely see me carrying one, FYI.) Jessica is by no implies adverse to some reasonably priced bag, but she鈥檚 not opposed to an outsized $3,000 designer bag, either. 鈥淭he Many Bags of Jessica Alba鈥?proves both of those points. (And is really deserving of a Part 2, I think鈥?Style present settings can range with the mundane (rows of seats as well as a even though runway) on the sublime (anything Chanel鈥檚 done inside the earlier five years), and Kate Spade normally prefers to get on the latter conclusion of your spectrum. To the Kate Spade Spring 2014 collection, Kate Spade designed an indoor garden party, the white pebbled entrance of which recalled Chanel鈥檚 spectacular Spring 2011 runway clearly show, also established in a garden established indoors.Kate Spade and Chanel are pretty different brands that do factors on incredibly different scales, not surprisingly, but Spade鈥檚 lush faux greenery formed a ideal backdrop for clothes that were being just about as 鈥渟pring鈥?as it gets - lemon-dotted separates, full-skirted frocks in checks and wide stripes, trim bags in light colours and pointed-toe pumps in everything from patent pastels to shiny holographic finishes. Kate Spade鈥檚 search is pretty, quite specific, and by now we all know it very well, but number of brands do a better job of harnessing their aesthetics than Spade. [url=]mcm online[/url] Givenchy Baggage Make Their Net-a-Porter DebutGivenchy handbags could be oddly hard to locate to the Internet. For any major, buzzy brand that permits its bag to become sold online, not all that numerous big web retailers bother to stock them. Bergdorf Goodman will sell you a Givenchy bag more than the Internet, but much-larger sister company Neiman Marcus will not. Neither will Saks, and up until finally late very last 7 days, neither would Net-a-Porter. Thankfully, that past part鈥檚 changed.

[url=]mcm belts[/url] As of Friday, you could shop a fairly great debut selection of Givenchy baggage at Net-a-Porter, including new-for-Fall 2013 styles like a fresh, more structured Pandora shoulder bag and also a colorblocked neutral model with the outdated Mini Pandora. Whilst we鈥檙e over the subject of mini, a new, tiny, crossbody version in the fan-favorite Nightingale is also newly on offer at NAP. Check out the site鈥檚 total Givenchy selection or shop our picks underneath!I've in no way considered of anything like a 鈥渃ommuter bag鈥?before, but if you live inside a place where much within your moving about is done by public transportation, you know one particular any time you see 1. No matter whether the bag will be carried by a man or woman, it needs to have a good deal of space, multiple pockets, a complete major closure and also a powerful, comfortable shoulder strap, at the quite the very least. Accurate to its name, the Coach Legacy Utility Flap Commuter Bag has all that and a lot more.So here鈥檚 what we have got during this bag: a entrance pocket for quick-reach items like your phone and keys, a flap-covered most important compartment for larger items, multiple interior items for minor bits and items, and equally a double-handle setup for hand-carrying and also a shoulder strap for鈥ell, in your shoulder. It is got all of the dude鈥檚 work-bag bases covered, and it does so in two multicolored neutral versions which can be colorblocked without having being colorblocked, in that tediously trendy way. [url=]mcm backpack mini[/url] Welcome into the PurseForum Roundup for September 6. We know we often remark around the swift passage of time, and this week is not any different! Exactly where did summertime go, and is it really nearly time for Vogue Week previously? Very well, actually we wasted no time pondering these matters, as it was off for the PurseForum to catch up on two weeks worth of reveals and conversations!It鈥檚 been some time since we have been in Nail Care, among our most active subforums, and it is been a really busy summer for our polish aficionados! Nail Care is whole of reference threads, advice, and not surprisingly fun polish exchanges of all forms. We are so fortunate to have dozens of really active swatch threads in our Reference Library, and polish of your working day threads for Chanel, YSL, the brand new Marc Jacobs line and numerous extra. Our members are so generous with their time and information and are so delighted to share their most current swatches, giving all of us an awesome resource for all our nail needs!The most up-to-date round on the Indie Polish Exchange bought off to some rousing start this 7 days, and as the box would make its way all over the world, our members are selecting and including to this pleasurable assortment and posting their picks during this exciting thread. Kristinized and aurawn have previously manufactured their selections, and we cant wait to determine what is upcoming! And, please never miss the Nail Art thread for some truly unique and interesting looks, including this lively manicure from fluttershy. Wow!PurseBlog readers recognize that colorful bag reveals generally catch our eye, which week in Coach, we curiously dropped into BonBonz鈥檚 鈥淚鈥檓 sporting white..鈥?expose and happily located lots of brilliant surprises! BonBonz scored some wonderful deals and we were particularly smitten with this classic duffle in rich, luscious moss. Somewhere else, Lisa Lisa shared her stunning Legacy Lowell in the shade of plum that is certainly certainly one of the prettiest hues we've seen among this fall鈥檚 offerings. We also spotted a colorful check out reveal - vgomes selected a deep ruby red for her to start with Coach timepiece: a Boyfriend observe that is simply great!Lots of Coach enthusiasts manufactured some super second-hand and vintage purchases in August, way too, so be guaranteed and drop by their thread to see these treasures, including SEWDimples鈥?exciting orange locate and ObsessedwithLV鈥檚 extremely, extremely classic shoulder bag that she is hoping to rehabilitate while using the help of Coach leather care experts! We like to view a wonderful older bag have a very chance at a whole new life and will be observing to check out how this develops.Rupert Sanderson Pumps Loeffler Randall Rider BagWe like new shoes. We are so blessed to have lots of PurseForum members eager and willing to share their new shoe purchases. The Glass Slipper continues to be brimming more than this summer with wonderful shoe bargains, too as super modeling shots inside the What Shoes are You Sporting Right now thread. Some of our favorites within the latter thread include things like CocoSapphire鈥檚 Gucci sandals that has a sweet bamboo element and her Moschino slides. Fellow shoe lover ericanjenson posted some terrific shoe and bag pairings, which showcased her Rupert Sanderson heels and her lovely In the Glass Slipper鈥檚 New Purchases thread, we promise that you just will not want to miss the vibrant Brian Atwood finds from jeninvan, gatorpooh鈥檚 Zanotti steals, LabelLover81鈥瞫 cute Valentino espadrille wedges along with the totally fabulous Alexander Wang Petra sandals Mia Bella wears so incredibly properly! We could expend all day checking out new shoes, and these represent just a wee fraction with the fabulous shoes we spotted this week!

[url=]mcm backpack outlet[/url] Coastal CaliforniaConversations inside the Playground have been pretty exciting recently. In General Discussion, which can be a mixed bag subforum that includes anything not specifically covered in any from the quite a few other areas in the PurseForum, you can imagine that anything is likely to pop up on Page One particular. This 7 days, we located a lively discussion around the use of terms of endearment, an exciting thread on luxurious spending along with a place to share your 鈥渨eird habits,鈥?when you are so inclined.In Television and Cinema, you can find a thread for most every single television exhibit or franchise and many present films too. Why not drop in and see what hot topics are within the table? We've a hot thread with the hit show Graceland, and not surprisingly the incredibly tense final episodes with the AMC series Breaking Lousy. You can also weigh in within the pros and cons in the cast selection to the Fifty Shades of Grey movie. From the way, that is just over the first page! Oh, and certainly enthusiasts of Dexter can join during the camaraderie in the thread dedicated on the show鈥檚 final time. When you are like us, you will appreciate the humor, predictions and wide variety of viewpoints that make these threads so enjoyable, whether as a lurker or participant.We would choose to say a unique thank you to twin-fun for posting the magnificent coastal California scenery while in the Random Picture Thread.Valentino Suede Bow BagOne with the most common handbag-focused areas on the forum would be the Bag Showcase. We stopped during this week and identified some outdated friends back on Page One, and some new bag collections in addition. Longtime member mga13 has continued to build and share her exquisitely curated assortment of bags and shoes, many of which she has waited years to acquire. During the earlier two weeks fans of her thread celebrated the addition of these wonderful Valentino sandals, and one more pair of stylish sandals by Marni.Dior Lady Dior Crocodile BagWhile visiting the Bag Showcase, be absolutely sure to choose some the perfect time to savor the new showcase by HermesParis, featuring luggage, shoes and accessories from Hermes and extra. And, in case you haven鈥檛 dropped by Kellyng鈥檚 thread featuring some Really Distinctive Baggage, this is often a ideal week to do so, as she has extra a stunning green crocodile Lady Dior and treated us to photographs of her remarkable Vivienne Tam dragon belts!Thank you a great deal of for stopping via the PurseBlog and joining within the Roundup. We glimpse forward to continuing to be your guide to our Forum, and hope to bring you lots much more conversations, baggage, and shoes as we wind our way into fall. Satisfied Weekend to all! [url=]mcm backpack small[/url] September鈥檚 by now been pretty superior to Kate Upton - she snagged the coveted Model from the Calendar year award within the Style Awards this week, and she鈥檚 currently doing her best Marilyn Monroe impersonation over the cover in the most recent issue of Vanity Fair, which celebrates the publication鈥檚 100th anniversary. Right here she is arriving in NYC for your Fashion Awards, carrying a Celine Crocodile Luggage Tote. You'll be able to store authentic, pre-owned Celine baggage at Portero.Even though most Celine croc luggage are merely croc-embossed leather-based, only authentic croc skin will do for your 2013 Model on the Yr! That鈥檚 appropriate, this one would be the real deal Holyfield. We simply cannot verify this croc Celine鈥檚 correct price, but a python model of this bag currently retails for $5,600, so an authentic croc variation would extremely likely be several thousand above that.It happened. I created it through my 20s and now I鈥檝e reached 30 years aged. I鈥檓 not one particular to worry about growing older; in actuality, I welcome it as with age arrives practical experience and knowledge, or so I hope. My 20s were being such an exciting time. I started PurseBlog and PurseForum when i was 21, graduated university, acquired married, moved to Ny and experienced a great deal. Growing up under no circumstances ends, and neither does experiencing life, so I鈥檓 excited to welcome my 30s and whatever they bring.To celebrate, in this article are 30 items with which I鈥檇 love to kick off this new decade of life, from new baggage to shoes to beauty items, let鈥檚 get the party started with the next 10 years.It doesn鈥檛 experience like slide, right? Suitable. Totally not tumble. If we just continue to keep telling ourselves this stuff, in excess of and above, maybe we can prolong the period of time that we get the attractive, crisp-in-the-morning, warm-in-the-afternoon portions of early tumble that happen to be so resplendent. That鈥檒l work, I assume. The power of positive imagining! We can harness it! Or, on the pretty least, it is Friday and we can harness some bag deals. Yeah, absolutely among those people two is going to happen. I'm able to feel it.


Здоровье уже совсем расшаталось?
Никак не удается стать богатым?
Любовь и взаимопонимание не приходят в Ваш дом?
Успех обходит Вас стороной?


Однако 93% взрослых жителей России ответили
положительно на 3 из этих вопросов!

И не знают как решить эти проблемы ...

Но выход есть всегда -

Все проблемы останутся в прошлом как только Талисман Судьбы окажется в ваших руках


Prepare servant moved:

I'm not be clear on how you're using the term objective. To be objective we must remove ourselves from the experience to see things as they are without bias. We must remove our influences from the past and present, our desires for the future, our likes and dislikes. Which is impossible. We can't use consumers either because they are not objective also.

Design is not an objective process. Design starts with a concept, an hypothesis, a vision - this is very necessary and subjective thing. We use our experience and skills then we spend time proving or disproving our approach with analysis, ideation, prototypes, testing and construction. All heavily influenced by what the design team wants to accomplish.

In regards to art and design. I think the highest honor to design is when it can be seen as artful. Art being the way it can connect to our human nature to our collective spirit. And "art" can fail too.

Thought-provoking article, thank you.

Since you've contended that it's the objective logicality of the arrangement and not the look that improves the functionality here, to truly compare these, wouldn't you need to do a ribbon-style layout of the Keynote groupings, and a keynote style layout of the power point groupings?

I'd be interested to know how you decided that the Keynote groupings were more logical than the Power point ones, because I struggle to see a strong logical priority of what kind of object you're working with over what kind of process you're doing with it. For instance, I and other designers of my acquaintance will often get the content mostly ready and then go right through and format, arrange and lay it out. This workflow would seem to favour the ribbon layout.

Yet the briefest glance makes Keynote look miles better.

But in a brief glance i am evaluating how approachable it is. Naturally, this is only one aspect of design, particularly of ux design.

I'd have to say, too, that these days I would have thought that the use of the term 'objective' as opposed to 'emotional' invites a little more framing than you've given. It's not the clean unproblematic concept that your unvarnished treatment of it seems to imply.

While objectivity has it's place, experiences are felt. What your saying goes back to the 80's. Efficiency efficiency!
The field is way beyond that approach. Subjectivity, culture, affect. These play a big role in design.
What good is usability if nobody feels those subjective emotions of pleasure and comfort when using it?
If we had a perfect understanding of the mind (and if everyone's minds were the same) then we could be design with objectivity. But we don't live in that type of world.

"Design is inherently an objective process" - I disagree. There is nothing inherently objective about design. On the same note, mental models are a theory, not objective truths in the same way that, say, a stone is objectively real. Mental models are that, models - models are always wrong - some are useful!

What "objective" does in this context is more like "look ma, I can be objective"...

I do not believe that the categories of subjective or objective are of relevance to design. Even more cloudy when the talk falls on "logical" decisions in design - what kind of logic? Inductive, deductive, abductive...? Design is interpretation of situations, contexts, people. Interpretations are not objective, neither are they subjective.

In much research, tallying might come across as more "objective" (for some), while (messy) qualitative research seems objective. People tend to forget that the numbers coming from quantiative research are based on a long network of assumptions, and do not in any way stand in for reality.

A very odd article...highly problematic assumptions being made here!


"Everything is subjective."

I'd say you're both right and wrong when referring to design. Unfortunately design can be very subjective, but this is a product of it being visual and therefore the uninitiated having the ability to comment on something they actually know little about.

Would you, for example, say that circuit-board design is subjective? Or aerofoil design? The design of tubing that caries fuel around a power-station? I'd argue that these things have a best and worst design scenario given their parameters. The same goes for UX design. Therefore I agree with the writer (and infact argue this point often), that design shouldn't be treated like you'd treat a kitchen redecoration, but more how you'd re-plan a motorway.


"... This also holds true for functionality: you're never sure if people are really going to use it in the way you intended. That's why research and evaluation is so important."

Spot on.

Interesting, controversial article. I guess the best thing you can go for is intersubjectivity: design something as much informed as possible through research, and evaluate it.

Cognitive psychology can definitely inform designers. I don't think the comparison between PowerPoint and Keynote proves the point however. Analysing the workflow and related tasks is always important. But it can inform designs in many ways. You can use it 1 on 1, by showing tasks as options. Maybe this is not the best option in case of creating slides, although no clear usage or satisfaction data is presented. So the evaluation is definitely subjective, makes me wonder about the design!

Furthermore, as Don Norman points out, emotional aspect can be functional. You can't design them directly, as you mention in this article, but you can design for them. This also holds true for functionality: you're never sure if people are really going to use it in the way you intended. That's why research and evaluation is so important.

The problem Microsoft products have is is that their products have way too many features. the problem the business has is it feels it needs to add more and more in order to sell more and more.

Brilliant article

Interesting article. Objectivity in design isn't really possible, however. Everything is subjective. The article also doesn't tell me how to do a design. But I now know why I hate the stupid ribbons so much.